Was Mirza Ghulam a Prophet or a liar? You be the judge!

Mirza Ghulam’s verdict on contradiction

===================================================================

Mirza Ghulam Qadiani has made his verdict pretty clear in regards to contradictions and those who make them. Below are the statements he made regarding this matter.

===================================================================

“Any wise and sensible person can never keep two different beliefs.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 3, Page # 220] (direct link to the page)

Izala Auham P.220

==================================================================

“Writings of a truthful and clear conscience person never contain any contradictions. Yes, if someone is a lunatic and insane, or such a hypocrite who is a yes man for flattering someone, his writings will of course be contradictory.”

- [Ruhani Khazain Volume 10, Page # 142] (direct link to the page)

Satt Bachan P.30

==================================================================

“Writings of liar compulsorily contains contradictions.”
- [Ruhani Khazain Volume 21, Page # 275] (direct link to the page)

Braheen e Ahmadiyya part 5, P.111

==================================================================

As it’s evident to see, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani stated that the writing of compulsive* liars contain contradictions. He mentions the following about liars and lying:

==================================================================

“Lying is no less than becoming a apostate”.
- [Ruhani Khazain Volume 17, Page # 56] (direct link to the page)

Tuhfa Golravea P.13

==================================================================

“oh you idiots, to lie is like eating shit”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 22, Page # 215] (direct link to the page)

Haqiqat ul Wahi P.207

==================================================================

“When a person is proven a liar in one instance, then he is no longer reliable in other matters/affairs”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 23, Page # 231] (direct link for the page)

Chashma Marafat P.223

==================================================================

“I do not talk of earthly thing, because I’m not from this earth, rather I say only what God puts in my mouth”

- [Ruhani-Khazain: Volume 23, Page # 485] (direct link to the page)
Paigham e Sulha P.63

==================================================================

“And Allah does not leave me on error for a moment it takes to bat an eyelid. He protects me from all error and guides me from the ways of the devil.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 8, Page # 272] (direct link to the page)

or a moment it takes

===================================================================

If the last two statements mentioned above are true, then we should not find any contradictions in the writings of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani. However, if contradictory statements are found, then Mirza Ghulam Qadiani is rendered  a liar, hypocrite, lunatic, shit eater and no less than a murtad (apostate) etc, by his own verdict.
None of the above attributes are befitting characteristics of a good Muslim, let alone someone claiming Prophethood & Messiahship, like Mirza Ghulam Qadiani.

===================================================================

Promised Messiah or simply a liar?

Was Mirza Ghulam Qadiani the promised Messiah, or simply a fabricator & Liar? 

===================================================================

In his book Izala Auham, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani wrote;

“I have claimed to be Maseel Maseeh, which stupid people thinks that it is The Promised Messiah.
I have never claimed to be the Messiah ibne Maryam. Anyone who accuses me of it, he is absolutely a liar and fabricator. For the last eight years, I have been announcing that I am only Maseel Maseeh; By that I mean that certain spiritual properties and nature and habits and virtues of Jesus^(AS) has been given to me as well by God Almighty.”

- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 3, Page # 192],  (direct link to the page)

(Izala Auham P190-191)

===================================================================

As you can see from the above reference, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani states how anyone who accused him of being Maseeh ibn Maryam, was a liar and a fabricator.

===================================================================

He would later go onto make the following claims;
 

“God named me Mary in the third volume of Baraheen-e-Ahmadia.  I was nurtured for two years as Mary and was raised in a womanly seclusion.  Then, the spirit of Jesus was breath into me just as was done with Mary.  Hence, I was considered to be pregnant in a metaphorical manner.  After a period of several months, not exceeding ten, I was made Jesus out of Mary by the revelation embodied in the last part of the fourth volume of Baraheen-e-Ahmadia; and thus, I became Jesus, son of Mary.  But, God did not inform me of this secret at that time.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 19, Page # 50] (direct link to the page)
Kashti Nooh P.46-47

 And;

“I swear upon God in whose hands is my life, that he has sent me and he only has named me prophet and he called me by the name Promised Messiah.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 22, Page # 503] (direct link to the page)

Haqiqat ul Wahi

 And also

“Thereafter, Divine revelations descended upon me
like torrential rain, affirming that I am the Promised
Messiah who was to come.”

- [The Essence of Islam: Volume 4, Page # 46]. (direct link to the page)

===================================================================

Also, as you may know, the followers of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani often refer to him as the ‘Promised Messiah’. So, what was Mirza Ghulam? Was he truly the Promised Messiah, or was he simply a fabricator and a liar, for proclaiming to be the Promised Messiah? You can decide for yourself.
===================================================================

    

Prophet or a Kafir?

Mirza Ghulam, a prophet of God, or a Kafir? Let’s see what his writings say:

====================================================================

“O People!… Do not be an enemy of Quran and after Khatamun Nabiyeen do not start new silsila (chain) of prophetic revelation.”
  - [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 4, Page # 335] (direct link to the page)

Asmani Faisla P.14

====================================================================

“I made it clear that I am not a Kafir; that Allah knows I am a Muslim, and I believe in all the articles of faith which the Ahl-e-Sunnah wal Jama‘at profess, that I believe in the Kalimah, that I face the Qibla when praying, that I am not a claimant to Prophethood and that, in fact, I consider such a claimant to be outside the pale of Islam.”
  - [Asmani Faisla (Heavenly Decree) English version, Page # 6]. (direct link to the page)

====================================================================

“How can it be permitted that I claim Prophethood and go out of the fold of Islam and join the party of Kaafirs (infidels)?”
- [Ruhani-Khazain: Volume 7, Page # 297] (direct link to the page)

Hamama tul Bushra P.79

====================================================================

“Can such a wretched fabricator who claims himself to be a Prophet and Messenger, have faith in Quran, and can such a person who have faith in Quran and believes the verse: ‘wala'kin Rasoolullahi wa Khataman Nabiyeen’ to be the word of Allah, say that I am also a Messenger and Prophet after Holy Prophet S.A.W?”
- [Ruhani-Khazain: Volume 11, Page # 27]. (direct link to the page)

Anjaam Aatham P.27

====================================================================

“So my madhab is that any person who in reality claims Prophethood and separates himself from the affluence of Prophet (saw) and openly declares himself as a Prophet of God, such a person is an atheist, non religious and most probably such a person would even introduce his own Kalimah, innovate his own method of prayers and give new religious rulings. So without a doubt, such a person is a brother of Musaylma Kazzab and there is no doubt of him being a Kafir. How can you say that such an evil person could believe in the Qur’an.”
- [Ruhani-Khazain: Volume 11, Page # 27 - 28] (direct link to the pages)

Anjaam Aatham P.27-28

====================================================================

“I am neither a claimant of Prophethood and nor I deny Miracles, Angels and Night of Power …. and after Syedna wa Maulana Muhammad S.A.W, Khatamul Mursaleen, i consider any claimant of Prophethood and Messengership to be a liar and Kafir (Infidel). I believe that Wahi (Revelation) of Messengership started on Adam (a.s) and ended upon Muhammad (S.A.W).”

- - [Majmua Ishtiharat (collection of advertisements) Page 230 - 231] (Link to the PDF)

====================================================================

As you can see from the above references, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani’s early beliefs were clear. Any new claimant of Prophethood would be a liar, kafir, infidel, a wretched fabricator and thus taking himself out of the pale of Islam. Now please take a look at some more of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani’s writings below:

“True God is that God who has sent his Messenger (Mirza Ghulam Qadiani) to Qadian.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 18, Page # 231] (direct link to the page)

Dafi ul Bala P.11

====================================================================

“As I’ve repeatedly said that the Kalaam which you hear from me is absolutely without any doubt, the Kalaam (Word) of God And I’m God’s Zilli and Baruzi Prophet, and it’s religious Waajib (incumbent) on every Muslim to follow my command and believe me as their Promised Messiah. And to everyone to whom my message has been delivered, even though he’s a Muslim, but he refuses to takes my rulings and neither believes that I’m the Promised Messiah nor does he consider my revelations divine, then he is answerable to heavens (God).“
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 19, Page # 95] (direct link to the page)

Tuhfat un Nadwa P.4

====================================================================

“I swear upon God in whose hands is my life, that he has sent me and only he has named me Prophet and he called me by the name Promised Messiah.”
- [Ruhani Khazain: Volume 22, Page # 503] (direct link to the page)

Haqiqat ul Wahi

====================================================================

In the letter sent to John Hugh Smyth-Pigott, Mirza signed the letter off with the words ‘The Prophet, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’.

====================================================================

When Mirza Ghulam Qadiani made his claims of Prophethood, according to his own fatwa, he himself became a liar, kafir, a wretched fabricator and took himself out of the pale of Islam. If Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was indeed a Prophet, then it would not be acceptable that Allah would allow any such contradictions within Mirza Ghulam Qadiani’s writings.

====================================================================

Dear Ahmadi Brothers and Sisters! Kindly open up your mind before it's too late.

May ALLAH guide you all to the right path. Indeed guidance only comes from ALLAH, He guides whom he wills.

Contact us:

Follow us on Twitter ----> Twitter
Like us on Facebook ----> Facebook
Ask us Questions ----> Ask.FM
Email us ----> ExQadiani@gmail.com
Youtube ----> Exposing Ahmadiyya
Dailymotion ----> Exposing Ahmadiyya
Vimeo ----> Exposing Ahmadiyya
Google+ ----> Exposing Ahmadiyya